Archive for Reviews and Critiques

Concluding Statement

As our posts attempted to communicate, mainstream attention to certain musical genres appears minimalistic and often ignorant. While most of the time genres such as experimental music and heavy metal (amongst others) do receive some mainstream coverage they are often disregarded as they don’t fit into the perceived definition of ‘popular music’ by mainstream press such as “Rolling Stone”. What results is a lack of acknowledgment for their importance within and contribution to the field of music.

Our posts highlight the reasons behind the lack of mainstream coverage as well as the motives behind these decisions – such as censorship. Because some music strays from the ‘norm’ or adopts themes that cause conflicts of interest it is often overlooked, ignored or put into a negative light. All music has value, however obscure or however standardised. But it is the obscure genres that get ignored, which we believe shouldn’t be the case.

The mainstream music press has similar attitudes towards other forms of music criticism, such as academic studies which are intended for industry and academic journals as opposed to the popular music press. Since the popular music press is predominantly read by fans, this type of research and comment on music is disregarded, as it often requires a higher level of academic cultural capital to understand.

Since one of the factors that makes any story newsworthy is timeliness, academic writing on music is also largely ignored since it is often not written until years after an artist has been and gone through the cycle of popuarlity and obscurity. This is unfortunate for the way the histoy of music is remembered, since the best analysis can often only be made in retrospect.

We hope you enjoyed our blog because we all definitely enjoyed contributing to it!

Lilen, Heath and Millie

Before They Were Famous…

Pretty Hate Machine

Retro Review: ‘Pretty Hate Machine’

As a pioneer of the industrial/darkwave genre, Trent Reznor’s first of his many masterpieces begins with the Nine Inch Nails 1989 release of Pretty Hate Machine. With a dominant sound of electronic synth mixed with noisy originality the album encapsulates a listener as it drags them into a new world of emotion. It begins with probably Nine Inch Nails‘ most recognised song, “Head like a Hole.” Driven by a beautifully catchy riff, it cascades into the electronic vivacity of “Terrible Lie.” The innovative style of music throughout the song (and the rest of the album) is enough to engage a listener of any style into the realms of industrial rock. As the album continues, it slowly progresses into famous songs such as “Kinda I want to’ and Nine Inch Nails’ first-ever produced song “Down in it”. While the song is a unique combination of rap-style vocals and electronic ‘noise’ it still follows the dominating sound of the album while at the same time, steers away from the conventions of the genre. Other notable compositions include the quiet (almost silent) tone of “Something I Can Never Have” which fixates on the emotional dysfunction of the creator, as well as the heavily electronic sounds of “Sin,” “The Only Time” and “Ringfinger.”

Lyrically, Pretty Hate Machine provides perhaps the most eloquent of all Nine Inch Nail releases. Songs such as “Head like a Hole,” “Terrible Lie,” “Something I Can Never Have” and “Ringfinger” each fixate on the boundaries of heart-break, power, greed, religion and ambiguity demonstrating Reznor’s ingenious capacity to express his ideas so that a listener vicariously experiences the feelings with him. Although his voice is not terribly versatile, it is just another essentially important instrument in the creation of the album’s industrial feel.

Overall, the original and pioneering sound of this album reflects the artistic nature of industrial rock’s most prominent master before he became one of the most notable icons in ‘popular music’ (Rolling Stone). Arguably it was this album that stimulated America’s initial interest in the industrial-rock group which, after the release of The Downward Spiral, later catapulted their name into the history books of Rock ‘n’ Roll. Because Pretty Hate Machine takes on a new and creative approach to music, it is truly recommended for those willing to experience the ways ‘music’, in this instance, has been twisted, deformed and mangled.

Lilen Pautasso

Words: 345

Evergrey, Eyefear & Transcending Mortality

Fast, Melodic & Full of Power

It was at a relatively small bar in Sydney’s centre where Evergrey were set to play their first ever show in Australia. While normally the more popular metal acts that visit Australia opt for larger, more spacious venues when touring, The Gaelic Theatre was ideal for the relatively unknown progressive metal quintet – atmospheric yet very personal. It was almost as if the band was playing for one large family out to celebrate their passion for the heavier sounds of the music sphere.

First up on the night were local act Transcending Mortality. I wasn’t particularly enthused when learning the band was to kick-start the show, particularly when the last time I saw them I left feeling as if I had lost my entire auditory sense – perhaps not their direct fault but still a part of it. Needless to say the group wasted no time entering into one of their heavier tracks titled Beyond Remembrance from their album The Lost Horizon. I was blown away. Instantly my previous thoughts on the group seemed unfairly prejudicial. The band progressed through their intensive mix of power metal via the unique sounds of guitarists Shane Linfoot and Jonathan Talan, drummer Matt Shriffer and (perhaps more so) vocalist Mike Zoias, pausing between songs to thank their loyal audience. Overall, a great set and enthusiastic performance was perfect as the start of the power metal evening.

Next up was Eyefear – one of Melbourne’s most loved power metal bands. With a new album out titled ‘A World Full of Grey’ (which has been critically acclaimed by many Australian reviewers) the band began most appropriately with a couple of new songs. Though the music provided by the band was just excellent, there was one thing that captured my full attention throughout the entire set – vocalist Danny Cecati. Using a vocal style made popular by metal groups such as Symphony X, Iron Maiden and King Diamond, Cecati was just brilliant in his vocal delivery providing a falsetto-like tone that surpassed every vocalist that night (and perhaps even some of his more famous influences). While Cecati provided a voice enough to make your hair stand on end, keyboardist Sammy Giaccotto was brilliant during his solo on ‘Searching for Forgiveness’ and the rest of the band excellent in their power metal consistency. Overall the group provided a one-hour set that was both musically and visually entertaining (due to Cecati’s extremely long hair!) proving to be an excellent group of musicians with huge future prospects.

A few minutes later and Evergrey appeared onstage dressed in jet black leather pants, black t-shirts and a handful of silver chains and accessories. Saluting the crowd with the iconic ‘devil-horn’ gesture the band looked ready to provide a full-on power metal assault. Starting with the Evergrey classic Blinded, the group provided a powerfully electric performance that drew an incredibly enthusiastic response from the crowd. As the song ended, the band stood back looking somewhat puzzled as lead singer Tom Englund walked up to the microphone and said just one thing – “wow”. Clearly astonished at the reaction and admiration provided by the Australian fans the band payed their respects by playing fan favourites Nosferatu, A Touch of Blessing and Solitude Within as well as treating the audience to a keyboard solo, guitar solo, drum solo, and two encores.

As the band progressed through new songs off album ‘Monday Morning Apocalypse’ the energy intensified and the band appeared to be putting all their might into the show. Then, as Evergrey appeared to be leaving, drummer Jonas Ekdahl remained onstage while an intense white light covered his drum kit. Starting with some subtle cymbal work he progressively ascended his pace to show off his unique power metal style. As his solo drew over 5 minutes he was joined by guitarist Henrik Danhage and keyboardist Rikard Zander. Suddenly the drumming was silenced by the unique and mysterious sound of Zander’s keyboard’s that was again overlapped by Danhage’s guitar work. Then it turned competitive. As one showed off on their instrument, the other responded with something louder, faster and heavier. While the competitiveness grew the drums came in, the band returned onstage and the theatre erupted into A Touch of Blessing. What came next was quite unusual. An obviously huge Evergrey fan walked onto the stage and started mimicking the guitarist’s movements. While the band (and the crowd) found him to be hilarious, Danhage decided to give the fan his guitar as an “opportunity to show of his Evergrey skills”. It was great to see the band’s good humour – any other famous band might have easily kicked him off the stage. Unfortunately as any good night at a metal gig the time had come for their final song of the night. As it finished each of the band members stood together in a neat line, linked hands and, in one theatrical movement, bowed together in appreciation of their “phenomenal audience”. Having been captivated by their legion of Aussie fans, Englund stepped up to the microphone – “my friends, after the show you all deserve a beer, thank you so much!”. And they weren’t kidding, when the show ended an announcement was made that Evergrey would come back out into the hall for an autograph session, to pose for photos and (for those who lingered around until 2am) have some beers.

Overall, though the setting was very simplistic and the stage relatively small, Evergrey, Eyefear and Transcending Mortality transformed the theatre into an arena. Australian fans were treated to an absolute blast of power metal provided by musicians who were obviously passionate and loyal to their profession.

Lilen Pautasso

Words: 900

Prog-Rock Review

Porcupine Tree - \

A Sentiment of Fear

It’s difficult to condense the brilliant collection of ideas and sounds featured on the newest addition to the Porcupine Tree discography Fear of a Blank Planet. The album comes five years after the release of prog-rock masterpiece In Absentia and two after the band’s most recent release Deadwing, making it a highly anticipated and equally suited addition to the group’s largely successful history.

Though the album follows a bleak and disturbing story of a troubled youth, the music is nothing short of brilliant. Intelligently composed around a highly original collection of sounds and coupled with eloquent song writing, the album mirrors the artistic qualities of, not only the album’s main creator Steven Wilson, but the genuine beauty of the progressive rock genre.

Based on a teenager’s disengagement with the wider society, the album provides an engaging (and harrowing) journey through the youth’s inescapable downward spiral, highlighting the destructive nature of the world around him. From the bleak confines of his bedroom to the emotional dysfunction caused by an excess of drugs, Porcupine Tree capture this powerful imagery with a cleverly selected musical composition.

The album opens with the title track, Fear of a Blank Planet which extends at a comfortable seven and a half minutes. The song begins with the typing of computer keys and slowly progresses so that it builds in intensity – a musical accompaniment that appears to perfectly mirror the turbulent life of the faded youth. Lyrically, the song details (quite graphically) exactly what the music projects. Lines such as “you feel no sun, you steal a gun, to kill time” are gripping as they provide the disturbing reality of the character in a way that is not overly simple or complex in language. Though not quite as lyrically creative as with past releases, primary songwriter Steven Wilson does enough to ensure the story fits perfectly with the music’s progressive direction. As the album progresses, so does the style of music – moving at graceful pace from soft (My Ashes) to heavy (Anesthetize) and going deeper into the youth’s troublesome psyche. Standout tracks include the melodic Way out of Here and ultimate prog-rock opus Anesthetize.

While the album, in comparison to previous releases, is noticeably different it is not a huge departure from the band’s easily recognised sound. In fact, Porcupine Tree, in maintaining their traditional style don’t turn their backs on new and more modern sounds. The album’s clever integration of many different genres make it a genuine recommendation for admirers of progressive and hard rock, blues, heavy metal and even pop.

To listen to some tracks visit Porcupine Tree’s official MySpace page: http://www.myspace.com/porcupinetree

Fear of a Blank Planet was released through RoadRunner Records in 2007.

Lilen Pautasso

Words: 424

Local Musos Shine at Launch

Newcastle’s Newest ‘Reflection’

A few years ago the name Benjalu would have surely puzzled many faces and raised no more than a few curious eyebrows. Today, however, it is a name that belongs to not only one of Newcastle’s increasingly loved new talents, but to four high school mates dedicated to their new musical profession.

On Friday 14th December, the group’s hard work was finally ‘road tested’ when Benjalu members Ben Gumbleton, Anthony Morris, Kelsley Nathan and Luke Elsley launched their first EP at The Queens Wharf Brewery in front of a 400-strong crowd. Together with many life-long friends, proud family members and a bunch of novice listeners the night quickly transformed into a folk-rock feast initiating an enthusiasm shared by band and peers alike. Despite having been given a measly one-hour slot, the group made good use of their time progressing with a few new songs including ‘Strange Feeling’, ‘Time Wasted’, ‘By Your Side’ and newest addition ‘My Shelter, My Fortress’. Complete with saxophones, clarinet, bongos and a harmonica, Benjalu put aside the basic ‘guitar-drum-bass’ convention and opted for a fresh and exciting new sound not often heard on the Newcastle life front.

Simply titled ‘Reflecting On’, the group performed most of the songs from the new EP in a way that was equally passionate as it was professional. While some songs are evidently influenced by artists such as Jack Johnson and The John Butler Trio, it is genuinely difficult to define the group’s unique musical characteristics or even limit their creative intuition into the strict boundaries of a genre. Instead each song takes on a uniquely different ‘personality’ fusing together elements of jazz, folk, blues and contemporary rock to maintain the group’s fresh sound as well as keep their listeners interested. This clever musical blend proved a huge hit with the high-spirited crowd who cheered at the end of every song, clapped their hands together with the band and sang along to their obvious favourite ‘By Your Side’.

Leading the night was the band’s charismatic lead singer and guitarist Ben Gumbleton (or ‘Gumby’ as he is affectionately known by friends) who spent the night thanking his strong band of supporters and dedicating songs to “the girlfriends of Benjalu”, “the Dudley gang”, “the long-time aficionados” and “all our new friends”. Meanwhile in the background bassist Anthony Morris together with drummer Kelsley Nathan maintained the group’s steady pulsating rhythm while Luke Elsley produced a blues-styled guitar lead coupled with a few notes on the harmonica.

While the night was finishing up Benjalu started their second last song to which they promised would be the most entertaining – they weren’t kidding. Starting off with the high-pitched sounds of the harmonica, Luke kick-starts the song followed by a slow progression of guitar and bass. A few minutes later and Gumby abandons his guitar, pulls out two drumsticks and begins a vividly enthusiastic drum duet with fellow member, Kelsley. As the song gradually builds with the inclusion of bongos and percussion, Anthony puts aside his bass and steals the limelight during an electric and highly entertaining clarinet solo that almost blew out the speakers and (according to him) his eardrums as well!

Despite the small room and slightly distorted sound it is difficult to deny that the night most certainly flourished for the Newcastle quartet. In fact the genuine lack of space can be pin-pointed to the number of people who came to watch rather than the actual venue – something the group definitely considered to be “absolutely amazing”. With a running time of just over an hour, Benjalu’s performance proved to be quite a success due not only to the large amount of EPs and T-Shirts sold, but to the passionate and loyal reception provided by the group’s growing audience. With a couple more shows set for the rest of 2007, Benjalu will, almost certainly, finish up the year knowing their reputation as one of Newcastle’s most popular new talents is gaining more fuel along the way.

Lilen Pautasso

Words: 665